Whole Wheat Sandwich Bread Recipe

Take your sandwich to the next level of scrumptious by using this Whole Wheat Sandwich Bread Recipe. Not only are whole grains hearty and healthy – they are delicious, too! Our virtually foolproof recipe uses the perfect balance of bread flour and whole wheat flour to create an American sandwich loaf that is soft, slightly chewy, and amazingly flavorful. You’ll get our top tips and easy steps for anyone – even beginners! – to make the best whole wheat homemade bread in your own kitchen.

Why We Love This Whole Wheat Sandwich Bread Recipe

There is really no comparing store-bought to a homemade loaf baked from scratch. The smell is so good, that every bite makes you crave for more.

Our fantastic classic sandwich bread has long been a family (and reader!) favorite. It’s easy to make, light and tasty, and is terrific to build crowd-pleasing sandwiches for any meal of the day.

This simple recipe is sure to be a hit. This is made with wheat flour, which is a good bit healthier compared to all-purpose flour. There are more nutrients in whole wheat sandwich bread – like fiber and protein – but it also has fewer net carbs.

Plus, the flavor is delightfully earthy and nutty with a hint of sweetness. And who doesn’t love a healthy option that is actually tasty as well?

Use a standing mixer to do the kneading work, but you can also easily make American sandwich bread by kneading by hand.

Ingredients are combined into a shaggy dough, proved, shaped, and then baked within only a couple of hours. Our recipe is great to prepare 3 standard-sized loaves or 4 small loaves – so no matter how many servings you want, this recipe is perfect for your needs. You can even freeze the it!

You’ll find quick facts and tips to choose the right flour for you below. Follow our no-fail baking steps, and before you know it you’ll be having yummy slices of bread ready to load with your favorite sandwich goodies.

Ingredients Needed to Make This Recipe

• Sugar – granulated white sugar or coconut sugar
• Warm water – not hot, but warm enough to activate the yeast (around 100º F)
• Milk – for the softest loaf
• Active dry yeast – or instant yeast
• Vegetable oil – or melted butter
• Egg – helps the loaf to rise
• Fine sea salt – just a pinch
• Bread flour – it has the ideal blend for a soft yet firm loaf of sandwich bread
• Whole wheat – we recommend white wheat flour (see below) or whole wheat Kamut for the best rise

The Best Wheat Flour For Sandwich Bread

Using white wheat flour (hard white wheat or red wheat) will produce a loaf that looks and tastes just like regular white sandwich bread. That makes this whole wheat recipe perfect for picky kids and those who are not fans of traditional wheat bread.

Hard wheat flour is higher in protein and gluten compared to softer wheat flour. It helps give baked goods that use yeast, like bread, a good, tall rise. Most whole wheat flour bags will identify which type of wheat is used, so just be sure to check the ingredients carefully.

Kamut wheat is an ancient grain that has remained unmodified and known for its nutrition, ease of digestibility, sweet nutty-buttery taste, and firm texture. 

We like using it for bread because it is high in protein but lower in gluten. And, Kamut whole wheat flour tastes delicious but looks just like traditional white bread.

We suggest using a 50 – 50 mixture of bread flour and white whole wheat flour, or Kamut flour, for the best results.

Tips For Success – Whole Grain Bread Recipe

So, let’s get ready to make that whole wheat sandwich dough!

Combine sugar, milk, and warm water in a large bowl and stir with a dough whisk or spoon. If using a stand mixer, use that bowl.

Pro Tip: Use warm water that is around 100ºF. If you use filtered water from the fridge for your bread dough recipes, take the chill off of the water by microwaving it for 30 seconds.

Sprinkle yeast on top of water, milk, and sugar.

Let stand for 10 minutes while the yeast dissolves and activates. Then, the mixture will become very foamy on top.

Add oil, egg, and salt to the yeast mixture. Stir with a dough whisk or spoon to combine.

If using a stand mixer, attach the bowl to the mixer, and connect the dough hook.

Slowly add the bread flour, one cup at a time, mixing well between cups. Then, add the whole wheat flour, one cup at a time.

The dough should look very shaggy. After mixing in the 3rd cup of whole wheat flour, the dough should start to come together as a ball.

Knead the dough for 1 minute, then cover with a clean, damp towel and let the dough rest for 10 minutes.

After letting the dough rest, knead it in a stand mixer for 7 minutes or by hand for 10 minutes. Not sure how to knead bread by hand? See below for tips!

Here are some tips to know if your bread dough is kneaded properly

Should bread dough be sticky?

Bread dough should be tacky but not sticky. A properly kneaded dough will be smooth like the inside of your cheek.

Does it pass the windowpane test?

The kneaded dough should be pliable and stretch 3″-4″ without tearing. You should be able to see through it, called the windowpane test, without it tearing.

Rising The American Sandwich Bread Dough

Cover bowl with a plastic wrap or a clean dampened kitchen towel then sit in a warm spot and let rise until doubled. Let the whole wheat dough rise for about 60 minutes, or until the dough has doubled in size.

Pro Tip: If your kitchen is cooler than 70º F, find a warmer place for your dough to rise. We recommend using a warmed oven, preheated to 200 degrees for 1-2 minutes then turned off. This will provide a warm environment for your dough to rise.

Punch down the dough to deflate it, and pull the sides into the middle.

Cover and let rise again until double, about 45 -60 minutes.

Divide the wheat sandwich bread dough. If you want the sandwich loaves to be the same size, weigh the dough to be sure it is divided evenly.

This recipe makes 2 traditional-sized loaves 8″ x 5″ (a standard bread pan) or 3 small loaves.

Roll out sandwich dough into rectangles about 2″ thick. Starting on the narrower end, roll up the dough. Pinch the ends.

Prepare the sandwich bread pans by spraying them with oil, even if they are nonstick pans. Place in pans, seam side down.

Preheat the oven to 350ºF. Cover and let rise for 30-45 minutes.

The loaf is done rising when it is 2″ over the top of the loaf pan or when you press the corner of the loaf 1/2″ with your finger, the indentation stays.

Baking The Homemade Whole Wheat Bread

Bake at 350ºF for 30-35 minutes for regular-sized pans, and 20-25 minutes for smaller loaf pans. (You can also use a bread machine if you have one).

It is done when the crust is firm and golden brown, and the underside of the loaf is firm and makes a hollow sound when tapped.

Not sure if your bread is done baking? Check the temperature with an instant-read thermometer. If it is 190º F in the center, then the loaf is done baking.

Let the pans rest for 5 minutes on a cooling rack. Then, remove the bread from the pan and let cool on the cooling rack for at least 20 minutes before you slice and serve your freshly baked American sandwich bread.

Optional: brush the top of the loaf with melted butter.

This is perfect for sandwiches or toasted and topped with our avocado spread.

Frequently Asked Questions